Search Issue Tracker

Won't Fix

Votes

0

Found in

5.4.0b1

Issue ID

758595

Regression

No

Unity does not correctly identify new packages, and in certain cases does not allow updating at all

--

-

- Attached to this report are 4 packages with the following contents:
- PackageA_V1:
-- PackageA/GameObjectA.1.prefab
-- PackageA/GameObjectA.2.prefab
-- PackageShared/GameObjectShared.1.prefab
-- PackageShared/GameObjectShared.2.prefab

- PackageA_V2:
-- PackageA/GameObjectA.1.prefab

- PackageB_V1:
-- PackageB/GameObjectB.1.prefab
-- PackageB/GameObjectB.2.prefab
-- PackageShared/GameObjectShared.1.prefab
-- PackageShared/GameObjectShared.2.prefab

- PackageB_V2:
-- PackageB/GameObjectB.1.prefab
-- PackageB/GameObjectB.2.prefab
-- PackageShared/GameObject.Shared.1.prefab

How to reproduce:

1. Open a new project
2. Import PackageA_V1
- It gets imported properly
3. Import PackageB_V1
- It gets imported, however it's not clear if PackageB metadata is stored separately for the contents of the PackageShared folder
4. Import PackageA_V2
- The default option is to "Re-install Package", which installs a new version of GameObjectA.1.prefab
- Unity does not recognise that certain files and folders were deleted in this package (and does not delete any files)
- It also cannot tell if PackageShared files were added via PackageA or PackageB
5. Import PackageB_V2
- Unity states that there is nothing to import from this package, as all assets are already in this project
- This is not optimal behaviour, as these are potentially completely new files
- End file result:
-- PackageA/GameObjectA.1.prefab from PackageA_V2
-- PackageA/GameObjectA.2.prefab from PackageA_V1
-- PackageB/GameObjectB.1.prefab from PackageB_V1
-- PackageB/GameObjectB.2.prefab from PackageB_V1
-- PackageShared/GameObjectShared.1.prefab from PackageA_V1 or PackageB_V1 (it is not immediately clear which one)
-- PackageShared/GameObjectShared.2.prefab from PackageA_V1 or PackageB_V1 (it is not immediately clear which one)
- Reproduced in Version 5.4.0b1 (3137382c8e08)
- New package import feature

- Won't fix: This feature is now in *legacy* mode and will be replaced in the future by a new packages manager system. The behaviour described in this bug is a result of current implementation design. To fix this issue would require a rewrite/redesign of the current implementation. We will instead focus our energy on the new system and make sure this bug does not present itself.

Add comment

Log in to post comment

All about bugs

View bugs we have successfully reproduced, and vote for the bugs you want to see fixed most urgently.