Search Issue Tracker

Fixed in 2019.3

Fixed in 2018.4, 2019.2

Votes

10

Found in

5.5.0p3

Issue ID

879696

Regression

No

Adding Cloth component to SkinnedMeshRenderer changes its bounds

Physics

-

Reproduction steps:
1. Open project attached(UnityBugRepro.zip)
2. Open scene (test)
3. Select Rig_Male_Thief_Thug -> Rig_Male_Thief_Thug_Body
4. Add cloth component to it.

Expected result: SkinnedMeshRenderer bounds will stay in its place.
Actual result: SkinnedMeshRenderer bounds changes position.

Fixed in: 2019.3.0a3

Reproduced on: 5.3.7p3, 5.4.4f1, 5.5.1p3, 5.6.0b8.

Comments (15)

  1. Fb9668f63e0579586d5582f86bccd6b7?d=mm

    stonebits

    Feb 09, 2020 23:26

    I'm seeing this in 2020.1.0a22

  2. Fca5476a343ff11369850590125bbe0c?d=mm

    studentfirst18

    Feb 08, 2020 16:55

    Heres a possible fix that worked in my case. https://www.polygon-treehouse.com/blog/2017/8/4/howtoponcho

    It says to add a empty game object, then add skin mesh renderer component, and finally add the cloth component. This worked for me and fixed the scaling issue. Hope this helps

  3. 3ea8707c3fb662f4672017472f1692cf?d=mm

    MostHated

    Oct 17, 2019 19:00

    None of the proposed fixes are working for me on 2019.2

  4. Da37c8122786e06969aca297cb5c264b?d=mm

    ElasticSea

    Sep 08, 2019 16:16

    It is fixed in 2018.4.8

  5. 1ef184756ff2918aaeb80a5ae3e61515?d=mm

    Skjalg

    Aug 26, 2019 09:40

    What does it mean that this is "By Design" in 2018.4 ? It broke during 2018.4 development...

    So much for LTS being the safest option for us developers...

  6. Da37c8122786e06969aca297cb5c264b?d=mm

    ElasticSea

    Aug 16, 2019 12:28

    Ok, my previous solution does not work in particular builds. Pretty sure this problem started appearing with 2018.4.3f1 there is also mention in the changelog: Physics Fixed issue with bounds in SkinnedMeshRenderer. (1153167)

  7. Da37c8122786e06969aca297cb5c264b?d=mm

    ElasticSea

    Aug 15, 2019 18:48

    I had the same issue I couldn't upgrade to 2019.2 due to various other cloth bugs so I just force the skinned mesh renderer bounds in a script. This might help someone. https://gist.github.com/ElasticSea/cd751d0240f057a2afc4b3b8ceb311cb

  8. 1ef184756ff2918aaeb80a5ae3e61515?d=mm

    Skjalg

    Aug 07, 2019 07:26

    Not sure if this is the same issue or not, but I still get missing Cloth in 2019.2.0f1 when a Cloth component has "Update When Offscreen" unchecked. I have to toggle it, then toggle it off again to make the Cloth appear.

  9. 07bde68c57c6fb67c4add8dfe45b97ad?d=mm

    mpete

    Aug 05, 2019 11:37

    I still have this problem in 2019.4.5

  10. 35b4b87227af8f7606f74ecc6ddecd32?d=mm

    Fritte

    May 27, 2019 12:04

    Same issue in Unity 2019.3.0a2 with HDRP.

Add comment

Log in to post comment

All about bugs

View bugs we have successfully reproduced, and vote for the bugs you want to see fixed most urgently.