Search Issue Tracker

By Design

Votes

0

Found in

Issue ID

1243268

Regression

No

Incorrect import when a skinned mesh has vertices unassigned

Asset Importers

-

When importing fbx with a skinned mesh that has vertices not assigned to any joint, they get arbitrarily get set to 1.

1. Open 'UnassignedVertices.fbx' in Maya/Max/Blender etc.
2. Play animation and notice that some vertices are unaffected by bones
3. Import fbx in Unity, Play animation

Expected result: Animation plays the same, unassigned vertices are supported

Actual results: Animation is incorrect, but you get a warning:
'ImportFBX Warnings: Mesh 'XYX' has # (out of #) vertices with no weight and bone assigned (they will be assigned to bone #0 with weight 1).

  1. Response avatar

    Resolution Note:

    For runtime optimizations we either skin the complete mesh or nothing at all. To do skinning on the complete mesh we need a weight and a bone for every vertex. When a vertex does not have a weight and a bone assigned we assign one for the user - as shown by the warning message. It is impossible to guess the correct bone that follows the users intend. The first bone is a best guess that I imagine solves it for most cases. But it is really something that should be authored by the user.

Add comment

Log in to post comment

All about bugs

View bugs we have successfully reproduced, and vote for the bugs you want to see fixed most urgently.