Search Issue Tracker

Fixed in 5.1.0

Votes

3

Found in

5.0.0f4

Issue ID

685180

Regression

No

Random Tree Rotation doesn't work

Terrain

-

To reproduce:
1. Open attached project
2. Open tree scene
3. Click place tree tab
4. Ensure that Random Tree Rotation is enabled
5. Paint some trees
6. Notice that random rotation doesn't work

Comments (19)

  1. 3f21bc8188b564894b9bd32ccef4fbb3?d=mm

    ErnieTheMighty

    Oct 08, 2018 12:58

    The issue is not solved.

  2. Ec385f3b0680c677aa6a611c90fdfa69?d=mm

    rocky1138

    Sep 26, 2018 05:14

    Here it is in action: https://gfycat.com/gifs/detail/InbornAgitatedEasternnewt

    Left bunch is painted trees from a GameObject which has an LOD script attached. Note that I get random rotation here but I lose wind.

    Middle is the game object dragged into the scene.

    Right bunch is painted but without the LOD script. Note that I get wind but no random rotation.

    Unity 2018.1.6f1

  3. Ec385f3b0680c677aa6a611c90fdfa69?d=mm

    rocky1138

    Sep 26, 2018 05:05

    I am experiencing this issue with Unity version 2018.1.6f1. Either I put my trees in a GameObject with an LOD attached to the parent which causes me to lose leaves moving in the wind, or I don't and get wind but no random rotation.

  4. B289b63605fec99475950bc1ea1800c9?d=mm

    sebagork

    Aug 06, 2018 23:22

    The problem is still there.

  5. 89154396aeea8de041561c88a6fbc44c?d=mm

    sciencedome_freelancer_laugs

    May 23, 2018 15:54

    It would really be amazing if this could be fixed rather sooner than later. Placing all your trees into LOD-groups just to get a random rotation is really annoying.

  6. Ec18988dd94df8a457e56b932828247e?d=mm

    Radzievskyi

    Nov 29, 2016 20:00

    Issue still not resolved in Unity 5.4.3f1 and 5.5.0 Beta 11.

    I many days search solution of this problem. But when I fix one, I found another problem.

    I try use very specific trees with cartoon style, so I can't use Unity Tree or Speedtree.

    For make custom tree rotate randomly - you need create Prefab with LOD of trees, and load this prefab to terrain. After this terrain can set random rotation of trees.

    But if use LOD prefab, is stop working wind (Bend Factor automatically hide from settings), and stop work randomization of colors.

    So now I have not good choice:
    - Use LOD and lost wind and random color;
    - Use one mesh Prefab, not have random rotation and not have LOD;

    Very sad, I still try find solution.

  7. E67c518e457c3404cf5dacd90c29434b?d=mm

    Darth-Zoddo

    Sep 29, 2016 07:00

    why does it say resolved?
    it's still here in Unity 5.4.0f.....

  8. 08975ccfbe0e765f3414bfa2fd6e521b?d=mm

    KBossler

    Sep 21, 2016 20:48

    Still an issue in 5.4.1f1 The only solution I have found (which is not a good one) is to make multiple version of the same tree prefab but rotated slightly. It means a lot more extra work and less overall variation. :(

  9. 4a58c1fdb1cf7cebc22776b0d7165c74?d=mm

    b4nj0

    Jul 01, 2016 17:41

    The problem is still present for Unity 5.3 Trees created with Unity Tree creator.
    The option for random rotation completely disappeared.

  10. 3290e34918c25e854060902830a89e9e?d=mm

    Brian2k

    Apr 04, 2016 11:02

    this is definetly still an issue...

Add comment

Log in to post comment

All about bugs

View bugs we have successfully reproduced, and vote for the bugs you want to see fixed most urgently.